Good. The Covid debacle revealed the scientific establishment to be corrupt to the core, and while I'd rather see audits, prosecutions, and prison sentences, taking away their unearned privileges is at least a step in the right direction.
FTA: The public comment period closes approximately July 13, 2026 (45 days from May 29 publication). Comments must be submitted to regulations.gov, Docket OMB-2026-0034.
A lot of focus has been put on the freedom of speech aspects of this — and rightly so — but my concern is that this is a much broader attempt to simply put control of research monies in the hands of the Trump administration for whatever purposes it serves those individuals.
It's essentially an assertion that they can do whatever they like with funds allocated for research, giving it to whoever they like, under whatever conditions they like, whenever they want.
Good. The Covid debacle revealed the scientific establishment to be corrupt to the core, and while I'd rather see audits, prosecutions, and prison sentences, taking away their unearned privileges is at least a step in the right direction.
> These appointees are explicitly forbidden from deferring to peer reviewers or routinely ratifying their recommendations.
In what world did someone think that's a good idea? Don't these rule changes need to be approved before enacted?
The rule is still open for comment.
FTA: The public comment period closes approximately July 13, 2026 (45 days from May 29 publication). Comments must be submitted to regulations.gov, Docket OMB-2026-0034.
A lot of focus has been put on the freedom of speech aspects of this — and rightly so — but my concern is that this is a much broader attempt to simply put control of research monies in the hands of the Trump administration for whatever purposes it serves those individuals.
It's essentially an assertion that they can do whatever they like with funds allocated for research, giving it to whoever they like, under whatever conditions they like, whenever they want.
Related discussion at the time last month:
WH proposes rules giving political appointees final approval on research grants
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48331511
What's Happening to Science in America
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48313687
[dead]